Dr Ian McLean, committed home gym user, Sydney, Australia
2009
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Previously, I only had experience of Concept Rower and a direct comparison is possible. After careful consideration of various rowers I purchased an E316 for use at home. The only other serious contender was the Concept2 but the Fluid Rower is a far superior product. Unfortunately it is rare to see a Fluid Rower in a gym environment whereas a Concept2 is almost quaranteed to be present.
It would be quicker to say where the Concept2 is slightly better than the Fluid Rower since there are only 2 marginal items.
The display on the Concept is slightly better, the PM3/4 display is brighter than the E316's IPM and is easier to use. Some worked examples within the IPM instructions would have helped to explain some of the functionality. Perhaps some additional guidance could be provided on the First Degree website. The other disadvantage of the Fluid Rower is that you will have to change the tank water so there may be a bit more maintenance required.
These are minor areas where the Concept2 is slightly better. It is like saying the First Degree football team beat the Concept team by 20-0 but the Concept team has the better scoreboard at it's ground.
I was going to say that the Concept team had a nicer looking football kit but the E316 looks so much better than the hospital grey Concept. The E316 looks the business and invites you to use it. The points of contact for the user are so much more comfortable than the Concept. The seat is more comfortable and the handle is superior to the nasty plastic of the Concept. The older Concept models had a better handle. The E316 footrest is functional and easy to adjust. The Fluid Rower seat is almost at chair height so you can sit down more easily. And, if you have had a long session it is easier to get up again!
When you have finished it is easy to stand the rower up although it is slightly heavy due to the uncompromising solid construction. Bringing it back down is also easy almost like launching a boat into the water.
The most important thing with a rower should be the rowing action. The Fluid Rower is totally superior to the Concept. Specifically, the resistance is constant and has a good feel. The Concept being an Air Rower has an initial resistance to overcome but then it virtually freewheels from the inertia at the start of the pull. If you stop pulling on the Concept, the counter keeps going. On the Fluid Rower it stops instantly. The workout is much harder and has a more natural feel with a constant resistance through the range of motion.
But one of the best things, instead of the anonymous sound of an Air Rower you have the swishing sound of water and the delight of watching it spin round on the E316. It is almost hypnotic.
Price wise the Concept and the more expensive Fluid Rowers are comparable. But anywhere other than the USA the Concept seems overpriced. In the UK you pay the same number in GBP that someone would pay in USD in the USA which is approx £1000 or $1000. The Concept should be at least 30% cheaper and it seems overpriced for non-USA customers. For this money Heart Rate kits should also be provided as standard by all manufacturers.
In conclusion, the First Degree Fluid Rower E316 is considered a far superior product than a Concept2.
Chris - Gloucester UK
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
My health club recently started offering group rowing sessions on your Fluid Rower S-350. What a great workout! I have done spinning for a couple of years, but this beats it hands down, because my arms and upper body are now getting the benefits too. I used to like to watch the Boat Race on TV and always wondered what it was like in one of those big boats, and now I think I understand the feeling of togetherness that there must be. Rowing is great! I only wish I had taken it up 20 years ago.
AF
London
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
We just got our new Wave Rower a couple of weeks ago, and all we can say is how pleased we are with our choice. We looked at other rowing machines a lot more expensive, but this seems every bit as good and certainly does all we want of it. It’s a seriously tough workout, and with the pulse monitor kit to go with it we can do long fat-burning pieces at target heart rate and really know we are now having the exercise we need to get back in shape and stay that way.
Best of all, living in an apartment it takes us just a few seconds after each daily workout to wheel it into a corner, stand it on end and it’s out of the way until the next time.
Well done Wave Fitness. What a great product!
Steve and Nell
Adelaide, Australia
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
WOW!
I JUST PURCHASED MY FLUID ROWER MONDAY AND TOOK DELIVERY YESTERDAY.
I'D BEEN ROWING ON ANOTHER BRAND (YOU KNOW WHO THEY ARE, IT HAS A WATER TANK TOO) THAT MY SISTER OWNS.
YOUR MACHINE IS FAR SUPERIOR. IN FACT, MY SISTER (WHO HAS ROWED BOTH COMPETITIVELY AND ON EQUIPMENT FOR YEARS) CAME OVER TO TRY MINE OUT AND SHE WAS THRILLED WITH IT TOO.
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
S.J. USA
I just purchased a Fluid Rower from Direct Commercial Fitness in Sun Prairie, WI and would like to relay to First Degree Fitness how extraordinarily pleased I am with my decision to purchase this product. As advertised, it is extremely well engineered and manufactured and most importantly, priced where it is easily the best value for money of any of the fitness equipment I own.
All this cardio equipment is owned to keep me from going crazy during Wisconsin's always balmy winter months. I am sure I'd go insane without the ability to cross train, and the Fluid Rower, aside from being a cost effective work of art, is just plain FUN to use! I was addicted after my first couple minutes on the machine.
..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
M.N.F. USA
After calling all of the fitness equipment stores in our area, most of them hadn't heard of your Fluid Rower. After leaving a message at one store, I got a call back telling me he would have a Fluid Rower in his store in a few days for us to try.
The next day, the manager of the Total Fitness Orange store called to say they had a machine all set up.
We went that day, tried it, bought it and wound up bringing it home.
I have just retired and my wife and I wanted a machine that would work for both of us and tie in with our love of the water. Your Fluid Rower was the perfect answer for us. Working out is like making water music. We love it!
We are grateful that First Degree Fitness made such a great machine.